- Remove allergy-causing particles that pass through it.
- Perform well consistently.
- Be economical to maintain.
- Handle a large volume of air efficiently.
How can an air cleaner help with allergies?
A good air cleaner reduces or removes the irritants
that cause allergic symptoms. You may choose a portable air cleaner for smaller spaces or a whole-house air cleaner that works
in conjunction with your forced-air system to provide cleaner air throughout your home.
What kinds of residential air cleaners are out
there?
There are basically two: furnace-mounted, whole-house units and portable single-room units. Both types
of cleaners have different models with varying methods of cleaning the air and capacities for doing so. Your dwelling may
help determine the right unit for your needs. A room air cleaner may be best in an apartment, for example, while a whole-house
unit might work better with a furnace and air conditioning system. It’s important to note that both room and system
air cleaners come in a variety of models, and that not all models use the same technology to clean the air.
Each kind
of air cleaner has its pros and cons, which may differ depending on your air-cleaning requirements. Take a look at what your
needs are based on your dwelling and allergies and talk to your professional HVACR contractor about the best kind for you.
What are the most effective air cleaners?
Media Air Cleaners
These units use high-efficiency
pleated filters, or “media,” to remove about 99% of larger particles, including many allergens. With irritants
in the spore and pollen range, they are as effective as HEPA filters but not as effective in filtering out the super-small
particulates such as bacteria, viruses, and respirable dust. Media air cleaners are cost effective compared to HEPA filters
because the filters are usually less expensive and generally need to be replaced only every one or two years.
HEPA Air Cleaners
HEPA (High Efficiency
Particulate Air) cleaners also use high efficiency pleated media to remove particles. To be designated HEPA, an air cleaner
must remove 99.97% of all particles 0.3 microns in size (such as dust and mold spores). Due to high cost, operational complications,
and other problems, HEPA units are usually seen in residential applications as one-room, portable units. When media in these
units need to be replaced, it’s often relatively expensive to do so. Some require charcoal filters that need to be cleaned
frequently. Warranties for HEPA cleaners are normally one to three years.
Electrostatic Air Filters
Electrostatic
air filters are not recognized as true high-efficiency air cleaners. However, they are generally recognized as being more
effective than the standard one-inch throw-away filters. Electrostatic air filters depend on the movement of the air through
the filter to give particles a weak electronic charge. Usually, these models are less than 20% efficient, with some models
having efficiencies below 5%. They need to be cleaned often, sometimes weekly, to maintain air flow. Electrostatic air filters
have warranties ranging from one year to lifetime.
Electronic Air Cleaners
There are two types
of electronic air cleaners. Both electrically charge particles and attract them to a collection material. The standard electronic
air cleaner will collect charged particles on a specially designed “plate.” Most electronic cleaners can obtain
95% efficiency or higher on various particles when the collection plates and ionizing wires are clean, but they can lose some
efficiency as they collect dirt.
A newer technology in electronic air cleaners is called
“electronically enhanced media” combining elements of both electronic and media air cleaners. Particles are electrically
charged and then collected by the massive air cleaning media of a traditional high-efficiency cleaner. Because the replacement
of the media is simple and there are no plates to clean, efficiency is maintained throughout the media’s life. Electronically
enhanced media air cleaners are 99% effective in the removal of numerous particle categories. Electronic air cleaners generally
have warranties of one to five years.
© Air Conditioning Contractors of America Association,
Inc., www.acca.org. Reprinted with permission.
